alternative health

On evidence and practise


An opinion piece to restart my blogging after my lovely holiday…

I’ve been reading ABC Therapeutics blog where Chris Alterio writes in response to a long comment by Michele Karnes suggesting that occupational therapists (and by inference all health care providers) ‘should be made aware of treatments that are offered to clients/patients, whether it is traditional or non-traditional, a long existing treatment or new one. This enables our OT profession and professionals to better educate the people they treat and interact with.’

I don’t have any particular concerns about this part of Michele’s comment – but I do have a problem with this part ‘while Evidence Based Practice is on all of our minds, and ultimately the best to utilize with our patients, if we only used treatments for all of these years we would have missed out on the many treatments that OT’s have historically (and still) use.’ (my emphasis)

It raises some concerning things for me – and while I don’t have answers for all of my concerns, I hope to stimulate some debate at least.

Chris writes in his blog ‘Just because people seek out alternative energy healing interventions doesn’t mean that it constitutes appropriate or ethical practice. In an article published in the Journal of the American Medical Association on this topic an author writes: “Given the extensive use of CAM services and the relative paucity of data concerning safety, patients may be putting themselves at risk by their use of these treatments. Only fully competent and licensed practitioners can help patients avoid such inappropriate use... Physicians can also ensure that patients do not abandon effective care and alert them to signs of possible fraud or danger.“‘

I’d add that licensing in itself does not inevitably lead to patients being helped to avoid inappropriate treatments. I also add this:

I think it also takes a critical and educated mind, a systematic approach to reviewing evidence, and considerable determination not to be swayed by forceful opinion. (more…)